Why does success have to mean progress?

 Facebook lately gives me some memories to browse every day.  I've been on the site for 12 years now, and it's fun to look back at what was on my mind four, seven, nine or more years ago to the day.  Yesterday, it dealt up something cute Janey said 12 years ago, when she was 5..."Don't put your fingers in ice cream!  That's NOT funny!" which I reported I didn't know the origin of.  I had a chuckle, but then started to think about how such random and funny utterances come up now and then from Janey, and that I'd still be surprised and happy to hear her say something like that today, all these years later.  She hasn't progressed in her speech.  She ebbs and flows, but her talking doesn't get better or worse much as the years go by.

For a minute, thinking about her lack of speech progress depressed me.  She's had so many years of school, of speech therapy, of ABA, of just hearing us talk to her.  Why hasn't her talking gotten better?  Why hasn't she made any progress?

And then I started to think---why is the only measure of success with kids like Janey that they progress?  Why are IEP goals always about reaching the next level?  Why do people (us included) hang on cool things she says to see if they are heralding a new era of talking?  Why does the fact that Janey stays steady with most skills not make us happy? 

Progress, it strikes me, is how we separate groups of kids with autism.  All kids diagnosed as being on the spectrum start out behind in some area.   But the ones we call "high functioning" or "mild" are the ones that learn new skills, that come close to climbing up to the norm, that get with the program quite literally.  Those like Janey, who mostly have a steady state, are by the very fact that they are the opposite of these successes considered failures.  Not that anyone would say that, not that it's what we think as parents, but if you look at measurable progress and there is none---what else would it be called?

What if that wasn't how we measured kids like Janey?  What if her occasional bursts of speech, her momentary shows of understanding we didn't know she had, were just seen as part of her autism?  What if we didn't hang onto the idea that she should be progressing?  What would we use instead to measure success?  What would be our goal?

Happiness.  Pleasure in daily routines.  Connections to others.  Just being herself, and having herself accepted as a meaningful member of society.  That's another way to measure success.

If I use that as my yardstick, I think Janey is a success.  She is happy much more of the time than she is sad.  She enjoys her daily routine---the bus ride, school, coming home to a meal made by Tony, watching her familiar movies, taking a car ride, jumping up and down, running in the driveway.  She has connections to many people---more than I do, probably.  She is loved at school and home, she has fans out in the community---she's a bit of a celebrity at the grocery store.  She is herself, always.  As for being accepted---well, we accept her, her school accepts her, our neighbors accept her.  Wider society---that's still a work in progress, the kind of progress I'm talking about here, and one that isn't her job but the job of said wider society.

I'm asked every year at her IEP meeting what my vision is for Janey.  If I were totally honest at these meetings, I'd say just one thing---happiness.  Let her be happy.  Give her reason to be happy.  Put supports in place so she is happy for all of her life.  That's success.

What Community Means

What does it mean to be part of the community?

I got a list of summer camps today.  There were hundreds listed.  Janey would be welcomed at none of them.

When searching for after school activities in this area, a big urban area, there are almost none that would accept Janey.  One great exception, which is not close enough to home for us to utilize it, is the Boys and Girls Club.  I wish the one with the fantastic sounding programs was not about an hour's drive from us in afternoon or evening traffic.

A younger Janey and her brother William, in front of our house

The city is full of plays, stores, concerts, museums, restaurants, movies----almost none of which I could take Janey to.

There are lots of wide open spaces around here.  Might be great for Janey---if not for the dogs off leash that run up to her, with well meaning owners saying "Oh, he won't hurt her!  He loves kids!".  Yeah, but Janey is terrified of your dogs, and that makes her unable to use yet another public place.

So, sometimes when I think about including Janey in the community, I get discouraged.  Or I laugh a bitter laugh.

This would be much harder to take if it were not for the fact that in our own little neighborhood, we have found community.

Our neighbors on both sides are wonderful people, people that delight in Janey.  When Janey screams outside, or laughs manically, or just is her own unique self, it means the world to me that I know she is accepted and understood by those living closest to us.

Anyone who has read this blog knows about Janey's love for the "ice cream store", a store that is currently a 7-11, although it's changed names a lot.  We go there almost every day.  She is always welcomed by the staff, and increasingly, by the regular customers.  I can't tell you how many little kindnesses she has been shown there.

The closest few grocery stores know Janey well, and go out of their way to make our shopping with her not only possible, but fun.  One of the workers at the local Shaw's Supermarket has a grandson with autism, and has actually given Janey presents and always gives her a hug.

Janey's new bus aide lives in our neighborhood.  She walks over every morning to ride the bus with Janey, and her sweet, kind nature makes our mornings.

We have a little bubble here, a small world where Janey is truly included in the community.  We have often noticed that she is more accepted here even by people who don't know her than she is in many places.  Our neighborhood is working class.  It's never been gentrified, and probably never will be.  It's not a fancy place.  And perhaps that's part of the reason it's accepting.  People here are not necessarily living the American Dream, defined strictly.  There seems to be more room in their worldview for those who might not be following the script of "good schools, good college, good job, nice house, good vacations, comfortable retirement".

So what does community mean?  It means a place where you are included, where you are accepted and valued and allowed to be part of the action.  We might not have a community in the sense of formal things like camps or lessons or culture, but our neighborhood has made Janey a community member, and that means so very much to us.

I wish the whole world was open to Janey.  In an ideal world, it would be.  But for now, it's good to have our own little corner of reality where Janey is part of the community.